This shows you the differences between two versions of the page.
Both sides previous revision Previous revision Next revision | Previous revision Last revision Both sides next revision | ||
designer_workshop:review_board_criteria [2013/08/27 19:08] Kjeld Kjeld's edits |
designer_workshop:review_board_criteria [2014/04/03 23:17] weathertop [Standard Criteria and Guidelines] |
||
---|---|---|---|
Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
- | ====== Review | + | ====== Review |
- | Board review is intended both to help designers produce better boards and to maintain a high level of quality for live maps on WarGear. However, when it comes down to it, board review is a matter of judgment. This page is meant to help all parties, both reviewers and board designers, by providing a transparent set of guidelines that seek to better define what is and is not expected of a board in order to meet WarGear standards. | + | Board review is intended both to help designers produce better boards and to maintain a high level of quality for live boards |
===== Mission ===== | ===== Mission ===== | ||
Line 7: | Line 7: | ||
The Review Board' | The Review Board' | ||
- | ===== Standards | + | ===== Standard Criteria and Guidelines |
- | WarGear Standards use the IEEE style guide for standards. | + | WarGear Standards use the IEEE style guide for standards. |
==== General Guidelines ==== | ==== General Guidelines ==== | ||
Line 33: | Line 33: | ||
* Make eliminations more valuable - card capture on, increase elimination bonus. | * Make eliminations more valuable - card capture on, increase elimination bonus. | ||
* Increase bottlenecks | * Increase bottlenecks | ||
- | * Create ' | + | * Create ' |
- | + | ==== Other ==== | |
- | + | ||
- | === Other === | + | |
* Every board should have a wiki page created for it on the [[proving_grounds: | * Every board should have a wiki page created for it on the [[proving_grounds: | ||
===== Protocols ===== | ===== Protocols ===== | ||
- | * Except for 2-player or 3-player boards, review games should always include at least 3 members of the Review Board. | + | * Except for 2-player or 3-player boards, review games should always include at least 3 members of the Review Board. |
* No board shall pass review until the review game is complete. | * No board shall pass review until the review game is complete. | ||
* Other members of the Review Board not participating in the game should feel welcome to comment, and the members in the game should take their comments into consideration. | * Other members of the Review Board not participating in the game should feel welcome to comment, and the members in the game should take their comments into consideration. | ||
- | * Only the members of the Review Board who are playing the review game should be responsible for deciding, by consensus, whether to pass or fail the board. If consensus is not possible, other members of the Review Board should be consulted, and if necessary a vote taken. The last member of the review board standing in the review game should be responsible for passing or failing the board, as decided. | + | * Only the members of the Review Board who are playing the review game should be responsible for deciding, by consensus, whether to pass or fail the board. If consensus is not possible, other members of the Review Board should be consulted, and if necessary a vote taken. The last member of the review board standing in the review game should be responsible for passing or failing the board, as decided |
^ ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ | ^ ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ | ||
^ [[designer_workshop: | ^ [[designer_workshop: | ||
^ ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ | ^ ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ |