Rating: 6.67 out of 10 based on 33 ratings
You can review this board once you have completed a Public game
Ratings
13 Oct 2022
All hail @psilofyr the creator!
Reviewed by PolarisC 
Perfect
Perfect
All hail @psilofyr the creator!
20 Sep 2022
Complex board. Very replayable. Downside is there are some bugs, and certain starts are significantly stronger than others.
Complex board. Very replayable. Downside is there are some bugs, and certain starts are significantly stronger than others.
6 Jun 2022
The board and game play takes some time to get used to. I played a Team Tournament on this board and it was great fun. Game play and Strategy are more complex than other boards. This board has become one of my favourite boards!
The board and game play takes some time to get used to. I played a Team Tournament on this board and it was great fun. Game play and Strategy are more complex than other boards. This board has become one of my favourite boards!
14 Apr 2022
Winds of Winter gets the 9/10.
House Variants rely a bit too much on luck.
Yes it can take a few games to learn, or if you read the rules and use the Board Explorer, you can figure out the quirks pretty easily.
Winds of Winter gets the 9/10.House Variants rely a bit too much on luck.
Yes it can take a few games to learn, or if you read the rules and use the Board Explorer, you can figure out the quirks pretty easily.
9 Dec 2021
This is a really tough, non-intuitive board, but I love it. I'm a little annoyed that the math for unit generation is something of a blackbox, but thematically it's spot on and I really like how restrictive troop movement is. By the endgame you really need to carefully plan your logistics and I think that makes for a really engaging game.
This is a really tough, non-intuitive board, but I love it. I'm a little annoyed that the math for unit generation is something of a blackbox, but thematically it's spot on and I really like how restrictive troop movement is. By the endgame you really need to carefully plan your logistics and I think that makes for a really engaging game.
11 May 2021
I am sure this could be one of the most popular boards of the site! It has some very interesting and even clever ideas. It is a pity there are so many flaws. It could become much better after a thorough review.
I am sure this could be one of the most popular boards of the site! It has some very interesting and even clever ideas. It is a pity there are so many flaws. It could become much better after a thorough review.
18 Nov 2020
This board has potential. But the borders are extremely unintuitive.
It is not at all obvious which borders exist and which do not. Several territories have absolutely no attacking border. This board is pretty much unplayable till the borders are fixed.
Reviewed by Pratik Abysmal
Abysmal
This board has potential. But the borders are extremely unintuitive. It is not at all obvious which borders exist and which do not. Several territories have absolutely no attacking border. This board is pretty much unplayable till the borders are fixed.
12 Jul 2020
Love this board!
Winds of winter being my favorite scenario, with house of winds now and then to keep some variety.
There are some small issues to be fixed (all named already) to make the board even better.
Love this board!Winds of winter being my favorite scenario, with house of winds now and then to keep some variety.
There are some small issues to be fixed (all named already) to make the board even better.
5 Jul 2019
This is a great board - the complexities are perfect for learning strategy.
I'm a beginner and I get my a$$ handed to me every time I play this. Love it!!
This is a great board - the complexities are perfect for learning strategy.I'm a beginner and I get my a$$ handed to me every time I play this. Love it!!
16 May 2019
I think this board is great, but be even better with a 20 army limit onthe seas and a 5 dice attack instead of six when attacking from the sea, except when attacking ports.
I think this board is great, but be even better with a 20 army limit onthe seas and a 5 dice attack instead of six when attacking from the sea, except when attacking ports.
21 Sep 2018
Favorite. The 8 sided dice for capitals is too wild. It should be +1 to highest die or each die instead.
Favorite. The 8 sided dice for capitals is too wild. It should be +1 to highest die or each die instead.
7 Apr 2017
Not enjoyable as the border layout is very confusing. Not for new players.
Not enjoyable as the border layout is very confusing. Not for new players.
12 Mar 2017
Lots of boarder confusion - things don't make logical sense. So only player who study this board and play a lot will benefit. Not a good board for newbies.
Lots of boarder confusion - things don't make logical sense. So only player who study this board and play a lot will benefit. Not a good board for newbies.
16 Aug 2016
There's a lot of thinking that goes in to playing this board. Big drawback is that you have to play (lose) several games before you figure out how to play.
There's a lot of thinking that goes in to playing this board. Big drawback is that you have to play (lose) several games before you figure out how to play.
